Skip to main content

Rhetorical Situations and Op/Eds


Objectivity and subjectivity, both can be facts, but where the facts are derived from is how these two terms differentiate. Objectivity, in writing, is where the authors writing is not influenced by ones feelings when the facts are being presented to the readers. On the other hand, subjective writing is influenced by the authors personal feelings and emotions on the matter. None the less, both types of writing still have the capabilities of presenting actual facts. 

In certain genre’s of writing, such as an op/ed (opposite to the editorial, or opinion editorial), it requires the author to be subjective in their writing. Transitioning from objectivity to subjectivity, in my opinion, can be slightly easier than transitioning from subjectivity to objectivity. Writing subjectively can be ‘easy' because you are able to freely expression your opinions based on how you feel purely, however, you must still represent the facts in the knowledgable way in order to still present yourself as a trustworthy author. As the author, you have the ability to choose a side in which your opinions match while introducing the facts in a way that favors the opinions. Although op/eds are subjective, I do believe in some sense it still can be objective a long as the logic in the facts also line up with subjective feelings - depending on the topic (but honestly, that may be wrong, but that is how I view it). For example, reading the Tuscon shooting op/eds, I felt were subjective because each author presented their opinion on the matter, while presenting the facts, but based it on their opinions in terms of legal issues, cultural issues, etc. To me, this was, in some sense, also objective because in this situation, I do not think any sensible person would try to make excuses and try to condemn the shooting.

Rhetorical situations consist of a speaker or a writer, an issue, a medium, and an audience. A blog is a perfect response to rhetorical situations. Blogs are person writing platforms, that allows the author to create writing pieces on matters they want to discuss or freely talk about, in order for an audience to view it. Normally, different blogs attract different audiences and therefore the blog is more relevant to that specific audience because the piece of writing relates to the audience in which is was created for. 

Every day it seems like there is another issue to tackle, and with lighting speed there are a ton of writers publishing their articles responding to the matter. One rhetorical situation topic that has specifically caught my eye - as well so so many other eyes - has been the new Nike advertisement controversy. On the ad featuring Colin Kaepernick, the tagline reads “believe in something even if it means sacrificing everything.” As a women of faith (Judaism - as discussed in some previous blogs), it is frequently a challenge living in, what I consider a secular world. In a country, that expresses separation in church and state but rarely accommodates to those standards. And so, pushing the actual events that led up to the campaign, the words written on it, are words that are truly relatable. This is a situation I would be interested responding to, by trying to relate the two situations, two worlds, and how they associate with the same issue. 

Disclaimer: I am in no way trying to criticize this country, because at the end of the day it is my home that I do love, but there are struggles I do feel like I have to deal with constantly. 

Op/eds are a perfect way of communicating rhetorical situations which respond to current, well talked about situations. These types of articles have a specific purpose, with some action the author thinks need to be taken and is written based on the opinions and beliefs the author has. They appeal to specific audiences because they voice a specific opinion. Not everyone agrees with the same opinion and beliefs and therefore op/eds will not appeal to everyone, but to a certain crowd, who do share those beliefs. 




Comments

  1. Hi there Sivan! Nicely done with your blog! I agree with you that op-ed articles are subjective but it can also be objective as long as the author neutralizes their opinions to the audience. The Nike Advertisement has been one of the most recent top stories that was happening and there are a lot of authors publishing their side of their story. Hence, people being subjective to the topic. Everyone will have different opinions and thats okay. I also liked how you did your disclaimer on your blog to make it very clear you are not trying to say anything bad about this country. Really great job!
    -Jenny

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like your point that subjectivity isn't necessarily bad, and that someone writing subjectively can still have a good points based on facts. That is true; in fact, the best op-eds are those that consider multiple vantage points using data and other evidence and can argue for the best one, which, of course, is the one the author advocates.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Sivan,

    With all the publicity surrounding Colin Kaepernick the controversy around this ad seems like it will lead to a juice argument. I also understand what you mean that although our country’s government is separated from religion. There are a lot of aspects of the American culture that accommodate Christian values more so than other religions. This was pointed out to me a little while ago in a conversion I had with an individual at my community college. They pointed out that there is more that just one holiday season. For Christians the holidays lay primarily in December and around April, and the school systems generally schedule their semesters in a way that accommodates for the celebration of these Christian holidays. However, for students of other faiths they have to work their holidays around the school schedule. With that said, I think you have a very interesting topic, and I look forward to reading your Op/Ed.

    Sincerely,

    Phillip Tarantino

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Sivan, I agree that even though being subjective means that you can express your opinions and biases, it is still needed to be written in a knowledgeable way to establish credibility. Well done explaining subjectivity vs. objectivity and how it relates to op/eds. I like how you also relate blogging as a subjective way of responding to different rhetorical situation and that they attract different audiences. I think that blogging is good starting tool to build different types of audiences who are interested in your writings as well as being yourself. The topic you are interested on making your op/ed about is interesting and I am looking forward to read your own opinion on this if ever you post it in your blog!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hey Sivan,

    It's really interesting to see how in this article you both hit the exact point of an op/ed and something that I feel kind of detracts from the tone of one. In this article, you give us a background of you being a woman of faith, which can give you a unique aspect and insight into a hard-hitting topic of today. On the other hand, you give a big disclaimer that you are in no way criticizing the country. Just because you love something doesn't mean it isn't subject to criticism, no matter what the public opinion may be. If you omitted that part, I feel like this piece in of itself could have been a fantastic op/ed (regardless of this, it's still a great, insightful piece). I'm very much looking forward to what you have to say about this topic.

    Clayton Staples

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mirabelli and Sterotypes

My first job was server at a small cafe that I still work at now. I had to learn skills such as, working the register, writing down orders, and most importantly, customer service skills. Within the customer service skills , I had to learn to be patient with everybody, time management, and even though the customer is wrong - “the customer is always right.” Some of these were difficult to learn, I quickly learned I work well under pressure, but as an introvert, it took a while to get used to the fact that I will be seeing customers that day and I will have to talk to them even though I don’t want to. It was also slightly difficult to learn how to please every single customer even when they are completely rude to me or obnoxiously wrong. Eventually, I got the hang of things and although at times it gets rough, I manage it.   Mirabelli’s discussion states how service workers do have a standard of literacy and how they have to have a standard of understanding their customers ...

Acquiring Authority

Imagine you went to the doctor’s office to get medical advice about a rash that you’ve developed - sounds weird but go with it. Instead of a properly trained, educated doctor treating you, an electrical engineer comes in to take care of you. Does this sound plausible? Not at all. Of course the electrical engineer is well educated, but not in the field you were looking for, and therefore would not trust their judgement very much, because they haven’t established authority in the specified field. This is exactly what I thought of while reading Ann Johns “Discourse Communities and Communities of Practice.”   Johns discusses that an individual acquires authority by expressing the language that the community shares. Therefore, in order to express the same language, you need to have at least some sort of education on the matter. I think of the ‘authority’ that Johns discusses goes hand-in-hand with trustworthiness. An individual gains respect and trustworthiness by showing ...

Six-Word Memoir

All it takes is one 'Hello'   I was born in Israel, lived there for 6 years, attended kindergarten there and lived in two houses. Moved to the Los Angeles, lived there for 2 years, attended 1 school. Moved to Las Vegas for two years, attended 2 school, and lived in 3 houses. Finally, moved to San Diego, where I am currently living in my second house and since I moved here up until the 12th grade, I attended 4 different schools. If you add that up, from ages 0-18 I lived in 8 different houses and attended 8 different schools (10 if you count higher education). I know this doesn't compare to a lot of people, but as a daughter of a chef and a teacher, who's professions do not require travel, i'd say my childhood involved a lot of moving around. As a child I did not keep in touch with my friends from my past school and so every new school I attended, I was essentially starting over in terms of making friends, learning the school system, meeting new neighbo...